The Weekend Summons

Your Friday afternoon dispatch from Alderson Law

 

✏️ Legal Pad

A Verdict Is Not a Check

On Thursday the International Court of Justice, the United Nations court in The Hague that hears disputes between countries, ruled 9 to 6 that Myanmar (Burma, for most of us) committed genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority. The court found that Myanmar's military, police and border guards killed some 10,000 civilians in a 2017 campaign of mass shootings, arson and sexual violence, and drove most of the region's 815,000 Rohingya across the border into Bangladesh. Many of them are still there.

There's no joke to make about any of that, and I won't try. But there's a lot here for a trial lawyer, because this was, at its most basic level, a civil case. Nobody goes to prison. One country sued another for breaking a treaty, the 1948 Genocide Convention, and won.

Start with who sued. It wasn't Bangladesh, which took in the refugees. It was The Gambia, a small West African nation roughly 7,000 miles away that didn't lose a citizen or a dollar. In an American courtroom that's a standing problem, and the case is over before lunch. The ICJ went the other way in 2022: every country that signed the Convention has a legal interest in seeing it obeyed, so any one of them can sue. When the promise is "we won't exterminate people," everybody is a proper plaintiff.

Then the burden of proof. Genocide isn't mass killing. It's certain acts committed with "intent to destroy, in whole or in part," a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. Nobody writes that intent down, so it has to be inferred from the pattern, and the court's rule is that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference from the evidence. If "brutal counterterrorism operation" is also a reasonable reading (and that was Myanmar's defense), the plaintiff loses.

That standard is why Croatia and Serbia both lost their genocide claims in 2015. It's why, in 2007, the court called the Srebrenica massacre genocide but held Serbia responsible only for failing to prevent and punish it. Until Thursday, no country had ever been found to have committed genocide itself. Six judges dissented and all fifteen wrote separately, which tells you how high the bar sits.

Now the part every plaintiff's lawyer knows (or learns quickly and painfully): a verdict is not a check. The court ordered Myanmar to let the Rohingya come home, to compensate them, and to investigate and punish the people responsible. The defendant is in the middle of a civil war. Its president, Min Aung Hlaing, was the military's commander in chief during the killings, so he's been ordered to investigate himself. The ICJ has no marshals. Enforcement runs through the U.N. Security Council (Ha!), where any one of five countries can veto it.

Closer to home: the United States signed the Convention in 1948, took forty years to ratify it, and did so with a reservation that nobody can haul us into the ICJ under it without our consent. Myanmar never carved out that clause. That's the only reason this case existed.

So was seven years of litigation worth it? The Journal reports that refugees crowded together in the camps to watch a three-hour reading in English, a language most of them don't speak, and cheered as volunteers translated. I've had clients who needed that more than they needed the money: somebody with authority saying, out loud, that what happened to you happened. Collecting is a different problem. Which brings me to this week’s Sidebar.

💡 Sidebar

Common Sense Tip That's Shockingly Uncommon No. 1: Buy UIM Insurance

Stop reading right now (but come back, because this week's Closing Arguments is a good one), call your insurance guy, and buy as much underinsured motorist coverage as they'll sell you.

Here's why. South Carolina lets a driver on the road with $25,000 in injury coverage per person, $50,000 per wreck, and $25,000 for property damage. Those numbers date to 2007. The state Senate voted to double them in 2025 and it didn't stick. (North Carolina went to 50/100/50 that July.) $25,000 can be gone before you're discharged from the emergency room.

And that's the driver who has insurance. The Insurance Research Council estimates that about one in ten South Carolina drivers has none at all, and that more than one in five is underinsured, meaning insured, but not for enough to cover the harm they cause. Put together, it's nearly a third of the cars around you on I-85.

The worst conversation in my job goes like this: you have $200,000 in medical bills, a surgery, and four months out of work, and the guy who ran the red light has $25,000. Can we sue him personally? Sure. See above: a verdict is not a check. People who carry minimum limits rarely have anything to collect.

So the question becomes what you have. South Carolina makes you carry UNinsured motorist coverage. But UNDERinsured is optional. Your insurer has to offer it, up to your liability limits (S.C. Code Ann. § 38-77-160), and a lot of people turned it down on a form they don't remember signing. It's one of the cheapest lines on your bill and the only one that protects you from everybody else's bad decisions. Pull your declarations page tonight. If it says "rejected" next to UIM, fix it before happy hour today.

⚖️ Closing Arguments

In re WKRP Turkey Drop Litigation

Thanksgiving is next week, which means it's time for the greatest Thanksgiving episode ever made: "Turkeys Away," from WKRP in Cincinnati, which aired October 30, 1978. If you haven't seen it, station manager Arthur "Big Guy" Carlson drops twenty live turkeys out of a helicopter over the Pinedale Shopping Mall, on the theory that they'll flutter down to grateful shoppers. They don't flutter. Newsman Les Nessman calls the whole thing live, Hindenburg style. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BGFtV6-ALoQ).

I've always watched it as a fan. This year I watched it as a plaintiff's lawyer, and folks, it's one of the most compelling cases I've ever reviewed. I'm now accepting clients to certify the class action.

Rule 23 is a layup. Numerosity: a full mall parking lot the week of Thanksgiving. Commonality: every class member was struck, nearly struck, or had a vehicle struck by the same defendant's poultry. Typicality: my class representative is a nice lady with a turkey-shaped dent in the hood of her Buick. Certified.

Liability is easier. The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur ("the thing speaks for itself") was born in 1863, when a barrel of flour fell out of a warehouse window and onto a man walking by. Byrne v. Boadle. Barrels of flour don't fall from the sky unless somebody was negligent. Neither do turkeys. Add a count for negligent supervision, because the only employee in that helicopter with Mr. Carlson was Herb Tarlek, a sales manager whose suits alone are evidence of poor judgment.

The defense rests on one of the great lines in television: "As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly." Thank you, Arthur. That's an admission by a party opponent, and it proves the only thing I need, which is that he never checked. A reasonable person knows a farm-raised turkey has the aerodynamics of a bowling ball. My star witness is Les Nessman, whose entire broadcast comes in as an excited utterance. "Oh, the humanity" is about as excited as an utterance gets. Assumption of the risk? Nobody walks into a shoe store accepting the risk of divebombing poultry.

I'll admit the case has problems. The turkeys have the best claims and no standing (unless The Gambia wants to file for them). The statute of limitations ran during the Carter administration. It's fiction, though only barely: the show's creator reportedly based it on a real radio giveaway of live turkeys off the back of a truck that ended in a brawl. And my biggest worry is the one I always have. A station that broke was carrying minimum limits; I can guarantee it. I haven't researched whether your UIM covers a helicopter. Call your insurance guy anyway.

Happy Thanksgiving.

Court is in recess- see you next Friday.

Ryan P. Alderson
Greenville, SC Personal Injury Firm Founder
Post A Comment